WAVERLY, Ohio (WXIX) - Three members of the Wagner family learned their fate Friday for their roles in the 2016 Pike County Massacre.

The decision as Judge Jonathan Hein announced that Edward “Jake” Wagner could one day be released from prison left people in the Pike County Courtroom in disbelief.

Jake Wagner had agreed to a life sentence without parole after a deal that was approved by now-retired Pike County Judge Randy Deering.

Judge Hein says that deal is not binding.

“If everybody wants the last judge’s sentencing deal they should have sentenced him under the last judge,” Hein said.

Many expected Jake Wagner would be sentenced to life without parole but that wasn’t the case.

“32 years out you get your chance because you cooperated. Because you did something to acknowledge responsibility for the crime,” Judge Hein said.

A couple of Rhoden family members gave victim impact statements but the most vocal was Andrea Shoemaker, the mother of Hannah Gilley, who died alongside her fiancée Frankie Rhoden.

”Greedy Jake Wagner. You. I want you to suffer. I want your mother to live and you boys to die as well as your dad. I want you to die so your mom knows the heartache of what it’s like to bury a child. It’s a heartache that never goes away,” Shoemaker said.

Shoemaker also had a message for both Jake and his brother George who is serving life without parole after he was found guilty in 2022.

“You are the spawns of Satan,” Shoemaker said.

Jake Wagner was given a chance to speak directly to the families but asked that he be allowed to turn around and face the Rhodens.

Wagner admitted to killing five of the eight family members including Hannah Rhoden, the mother of the couple’s then two-and-a-half year old daughter.

“I hope your daughter hates you as much as I hate you with the passion and with as much heart as I hate you, Jake Wagner,” Shoemaker said.

“There’s no amount of apology I could give today. No amount of an explanation. No thing I can do to help you ease the pain that you have. Loss. Anger. Hate,” Jake Wagner said.

Wagner told the family that he became a born again Christian in the six years that he’s been incarcerated.

”I’m sorry for what I’ve done and I am glad that I got caught. I a hundred percent believe that it was Jesus who made me get caught,” he said.

Judge Hein sentenced Angela Wagner to 30 years in prison without the possibility of parole.

She read from a prepared script where she said to the Rhoden family that she felt their pain.

‘I know their pain must be unbearable because separated by my family, the one’s I love most in the world, brings me unbearable suffering,” Angela said.

Angela Wagner’s mother, Rita Newcomb, was also sentenced to five years of probation and a suspended sentence of 90 days of which she has already served seven.

As part of their plea deals, Jake and Angela Wagner both testified for the state against the eldest Wagner son, George Wagner IV, at his 2022 murder trial.

It’s not clear whether they will return to the stand to testify for the state again, this time against Jake’s father and Angela’s husband, George “Billy” Wagner III, 53, since they’ve already been sentenced.

Complete Coverage | Pike County Massacre

Victims killed more than 8 years ago

The victims of the April 2016 massacre were Christopher Rhoden Sr., 40; his older brother, Kenneth Rhoden, 44; his cousin, Gary Rhoden, 38; Chris Rhoden Sr.’s former wife, Dana Lynn Rhoden, 37, and their children: Clarence “Frankie” Rhoden, 20, Hanna May Rhoden, 19, Christopher Rhoden Jr., 16, and Frankie’s fiancé, Hannah “Hazel” Gilley, 20.

Two infants and a toddler were spared by the killers and left behind at the murder scenes: a 5-day-old baby girl, a 6-month-old baby boy, and a 3-year-old boy.

Prosecutors have said the motive in the murders was the custody and control of the young daughter of Jake Wagner and one of the victims he confessed to shooting in the head twice, Hanna May Rhoden, 19.

The young couple began dating when she was 13 and he was 18. She became pregnant with their daughter at 15.

They broke up in 2015 after their daughter was born in 2013.

Jake Wagner testified during his brother’s trial he didn’t want the relationship to end.

Hanna Rhoden had a second child, a baby girl, with another man and was dating another man at the time of her murder.

Her baby was just five days old when the victims were found on the morning of April 22, 2016.

Jake Wagner testified during his brother’s trial that he shot most of the victims, including Hanna Rhoden as she was propped up in bed breastfeeding her new infant.

He said on the stand he positioned her body after he shot her so she could keep breastfeeding her newborn, whose life he spared.

He also testified he picked up the shell casings and cell phones and took them.

But, according to other testimony, he missed one shell casing that investigators found under the baby’s crib.

George Wagner IV, 33, was convicted of all counts including eight counts of murder even though the state and defense both agreed he never shot anyone and Jake Wagner also testified to that.

George Wagner IV is currently appealing his conviction and asking that his sentence be thrown out: eight life sentences and 121 years on 16 other charges.

Billy Wagner’s trial was set to begin on Jan. 6, but a change of venue followed by a flurry of court filings has delayed that.

He has pleaded not guilty all 22 charges, including eight counts of aggravated murder, from the execution-style slayings of his son’s ex-girlfriend and seven of her family members in April 2016.

Jake Wagner testified he shot 5 of the 8 victims

Jake Wagner pleaded guilty in April 2021 to eight counts of aggravated murder and 15 other charges including felony conspiracy, four counts of aggravated burglary and multiple counts of tampering with evidence.

In all, Jake pleaded guilty to 23 charges.

As part of the plea deal, he agreed to a sentence of eight life sentences without parole and to cooperate with prosecutors and testify against his family members.

“We are fully satisfied,” Wagner’s defense said during the hearing on April 22, 2021. “He knows he’s going to die in prison without any judicial relief.”

Jake Wagner then testified for the state the following year against his own brother.

Jake Wagner shot and killed five of the victims, including the mother of his then 2-and-a-half year old daughter, Hanna May Rhoden, 19, and shot and wounded a sixth, her father Chris Rhoden Sr., according to his confession and his testimony.

Special Prosecutor Angie Canepa has said Jake confessed and apologized for the crimes. In an interview, he led investigators to the weapons and vehicles used in the killings.

‘I am more than sorry but that’s not enough’

Angela Wagner pleaded in September 2021 to conspiracy to commit aggravated murder, several counts of aggravated burglary, tampering with evidence, and other charges as part of a plea deal.

Eight counts of aggravated murder were dismissed.

The prosecution said at that time they were recommending she receive 30 years with no possibility of the death penalty.

Angela Wagner confirmed on the stand at her eldest son’s trial that her entire family, including herself, participated in the massacre. She was not present, however, when the slayings occurred, she stressed.

Jake Wagner backed that up in his testimony, saying on the stand that he and his father did all the shooting after the family plotted and planned the killings for months.

He said he had to talk his mom and brother into it.

One of George IV’s defense attorneys asked Angela at his trial if the goal of her plea deal was to try to get out of prison eventually one day and see her grandchildren.

Yes, she responded. She also testified she had regret and remorse and “I am more than sorry but that’s not enough.”

‘It’s not a good, Christian thing to lie’

Now 69, Newcomb withdrew her plea of not guilty in Pike County Common Pleas Court five years ago and entered a plea of guilty to an obstruction official business charge, a misdemeanor.

That crime is punishable by up to 90 days in jail, prosecutors said at the time.

She was accused of forging custody documents related to the case and then lying about it to a grand jury and to investigators.

When then-Judge Randy Deering asked Newcomb if she was coerced into pleading guilty, she responded: “It’s not a good, Christian thing to lie, so I didn’t want to do that anymore.”

One of the special prosecutors, Canepa, has said in court a handwriting expert determined Newcomb did not sign the custody documents herself.

Canepa also has said Newcomb admitted to falsely testifying before the grand jury and investigators because her daughter, Angela Wagner, told her to.

Do you have a photo or video of a breaking news story? Send it to us here with a brief description.

Copyright 2024 WXIX. All rights reserved.